407 Market Street
Sugar Momma’s features homemade pies, by the slice or to go, frozen pies, and sometimes fried pies. Local favorites are coconut cream, cheesecake pecan, and bacon apple. The shop is filled with a large assortment of bulk candies, Amish and German candies, retro candies, Ted Drewes frozen custard, and Giofre Apiaries honey ice cream. The shop offers German and Hermann souvenirs and lots of gift merchandise.